Live Match Thread: Australia A v USA XV

Barely a week after the All Blacks put 43 on the Wallabies in Sydney, Australian rugby has packed its bags for Tennessee. Stephen Larkham’s Australia A side opens a two-match series against a USA XV in Nashville, with a debutant at 13, a flyhalf debate bubbling away and an Australian-born lock waiting in the opposition engine room.


Australia A v USA XV Preview: Nashville

Music City Muscle Meets the Moose

Venue: Geodis Park, Nashville | Date/Time: Sunday 25 October, 8:00am AEST | Referee: Katsuki Furuse

The Lowdown

Old heads on a development tour. The Rugby Australia team announcement confirmed nine Wallabies in the 23, and the entire tight five has worn gold. Tom Robertson, captain Matt Faessler and Zane Nonggorr pack down in the front row, with Nick Frost and Miles Amatosero at lock.

Not everyone is sold on the idea. A development tour featuring blokes with Test caps by the bucketload has raised eyebrows, with Robertson copping most of the questions. There is logic to it, though. The word is Frost needs match minutes on his way back from injury ahead of the spring tour. And with a home World Cup in 2027, plenty reckon Australia’s loosehead stocks aren’t exactly overflowing.

Larkham, who doubles as Brumbies coach, is happy with the mix: “As coaches, we think this team has a good mix of experienced Wallabies who can lead the way for some younger players who have earned the right to test themselves for the first time at international level.”

The kids get their crack. Kadin Pritchard, 22, makes his senior debut in gold at outside centre. It comes off a solid Super Rugby Pacific season and a call-up to the Wallabies squad for the Sydney Bledisloe. He partners Brumbies clubmate David Feliuai, giving Australia A a super-sized midfield that already knows each other’s lines.

Will Harris arrives in the back row with a trophy cabinet that needs dusting: the Shute Shield, the Super Rugby AUS title, and Player of the Final. He joins Rory Scott and Joe Brial in a mobile, physical loose trio. In-form Force scrumhalf Nathan Hastie gets the 9 jersey.

The Underdog sports news mascot, a dog in a green tracksuit, holding a microphone inside a neon-lit broadcast control room with sports monitors.

The bench has its own story. Former Australian Under 20s captains Eamon Doyle and Toby Macpherson both get their first senior Australian run. Doyle, who skippered the Waratahs in Super Rugby AUS, covers the back row, while Macpherson covers lock. Olympian Lachie Anderson rounds out the 23.

The flyhalf fuss. Here is where the debate gets loud. Tane Edmed, Wallaby number 990, starts at 10. Harry McLaughlin-Phillips sits on the bench a week after a debut cameo off the pine in Sydney. Many reckon HMP needed a start here, and some are asking why Max Burey can’t get a look in at all.

The likeliest read is workload management after a big year for HMP. With a second match in New Jersey, the 10 jersey and a few omissions, Lomax among them, could look different next week.

Don’t sleep on the Eagles. USA Rugby is billing this as a training series, but the hosts are no pushovers. The Americans are unbeaten in the World Rugby Nations Cup and top their pool. They arrive off an intensive training block in Japan after the Pacific Nations Cup. This series is their final dress rehearsal before France, where they face Hong Kong on 6 November before Romania and Georgia.

Coach Scott Lawrence has injuries to manage and is backing his new faces: “Test rugby demands resilience. Injuries can create opportunities, and we have players ready to step forward to fill key positions for the first time.”

Oscar Lennon debuts at scrumhalf ahead of Ruben De Haas. He is paired with Chris Hilsenbeck, who kicked the clutch match-winner against Portugal in July. Captain Jason Damm has played in both the tight five and back row this season and locks the scrum.

The Moose on the loose. The lock alongside Damm will be very familiar to Queensland club fans. Nathan Den Hoedt came through Sunnybank, Feliuai’s club too, captained Randwick and played for Brisbane City before heading overseas at 23.

From there, Moose had stints with the LA Giltinis and Houston SaberCats before landing at the Chicago Hounds. He was part of Chicago’s undefeated Major League Rugby title run, then earned his USA Eagles debut in July. On Sunday, the Australian-born lock goes head to head with Frost and Amatosero.

Add former Wallaby Nathan Grey running the American defence, and the Eagles will know Australian habits better than most.

Prediction

Australia A should own the set piece. An all-Wallaby tight five is the biggest edge on paper, even against a USA front row with a formidable reputation, and if Hastie gets quick ball, the Pritchard–Feliuai combination will have room to run. Expect the hosts to come out swinging in front of a doubleheader crowd that also catches the USA Women against Italy. Hilsenbeck’s boot can keep them in touch for an hour.

The difference will be the class in gold. Nine Wallabies across the 23, including Thomas and McLaughlin-Phillips off the bench, should pull Australia A clear late. The real watch point is Edmed: a composed 80 here quietens the noise, while a scratchy one only turns up the volume on HMP.

Prediction: Australia A by 17

Catch it live on Stan Sport. The second clash is in New Jersey on Saturday 31 October.

Advertisement for custom Rugby Union board shorts featuring classic match scenes, inviting visitors to support the site by making a purchase.

Match Squads

Australia A

  1. Tom Robertson (Western Force)
  2. Matt Faessler (c) (Queensland Reds)
  3. Zane Nonggorr (Queensland Reds)
  4. Nick Frost (ACT Brumbies)
  5. Miles Amatosero (NSW Waratahs)
  6. Will Harris (Western Force)
  7. Rory Scott (ACT Brumbies)
  8. Joe Brial (Queensland Reds)
  9. Nathan Hastie (Western Force)
  10. Tane Edmed (ACT Brumbies)
  11. Dylan Pietsch (Western Force)
  12. David Feliuai (ACT Brumbies)
  13. Kadin Pritchard (ACT Brumbies)
  14. Tim Ryan (Queensland Reds)
  15. Mac Grealy (Western Force)

Replacements: 16. Ethan Dobbins (NSW Waratahs), 17. Tom Lambert (Queensland Reds), 18. Rhys van Nek (ACT Brumbies), 19. Toby Macpherson (ACT Brumbies), 20. Eamon Doyle (NSW Waratahs), 21. Kalani Thomas (Queensland Reds), 22. Harry McLaughlin-Phillips (Western Force), 23. Lachie Anderson (Queensland Reds)

USA XV

  1. Payton Telea-Ilalio
  2. Shilo Klein
  3. Tonga Kofe
  4. Nathan Den Hoedt
  5. Jason Damm (c)
  6. Benjamin Bonasso
  7. Paddy Ryan
  8. Makeen Alikhan
  9. Oscar Lennon
  10. Chris Hilsenbeck
  11. Mark O’Keeffe
  12. Dominic Besag
  13. Tavite Lopeti
  14. Noah Brown
  15. Michael Baska

Replacements: 16. Kaleb Geiger, 17. Ezekiel Lindenmuth, 18. Mason Pedersen, 19. Sam Golla, 20. Marno Redelinghuys, 21. Jamason Fa’anana-Schultz, 22. Ruben De Haas, 23. Luke Carty

Scroll inside the box for match stats

Avatar photo

Ben Casey

Ben Casey is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of The Underdog. An outback country publican and independent sports analyst, Ben brings decades of grassroots rugby experience and tactical knowledge to his reporting. Frustrated by mainstream clickbait, he specializes in deep-dive Super Rugby analysis, honest match reporting, and holding Australian sports governance to a higher standard.

Articles: 471
Subscribe
Notify of
21 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Mirt
One of the Pack
Mirt
18 days ago

Lomax looks like a smaller version of Suaalii so far. Put Thomas over with a no look pass, looks to have a weak left hand pass but I’ll have to watch that for confirmation, they haven’t been able to get him involved in the kick game yet.

Mirt
One of the Pack
Mirt
18 days ago
Reply to  Mirt

Thomas has kicked twice now for Lomax in the first 3 min of the second half. 50% result

Mirt
One of the Pack
Mirt
18 days ago
Reply to  Mirt

Not sure in the benefit of replacing Lomax with Edmed

Mirt
One of the Pack
Mirt
18 days ago

Anyone else looking for a live thread, I’m cranking up last weeks again

perthstayer
perthstayer
24 days ago

Wallabies/ HK is going to be very ugly.

Mirt
One of the Pack
Mirt
18 days ago
Reply to  perthstayer

Next week as well as Nations Championship there’s the Nations Cup with USA playing Hong Kong, let’s see how that pans out.

Our RWC opener could be a hit out for the unlikeliest in the squad for game time

perthstayer
perthstayer
18 days ago
Reply to  Mirt

Great. Showing off our 2nd XV in RWC curtain raiser.

Basos
Basos
24 days ago

Good to see the Yanky spectators getting into the swing of things.

Basos
Basos
24 days ago

What an idiot. Feliuai actually came up to tackle around the head and deserved the Red. I have never been impressed with Pritchard because he seems one paced and does not accelerate through the gap.

Reds Harry
Reds Harry
24 days ago

Aus up 40-12 at 55 minutes. It’s become loose and scrappy, Aus A now making handling errors like USA. Benches on.

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
24 days ago

Good hit out for fringe players no real standouts..Inside centre looked good before silly high shot and Pritchard creative enough to suggest a Wallabies cap at some stage..Frost Canham combo worth a look at some stage.

Reds Harry
Reds Harry
24 days ago
Reply to  Antonio lover

Hastie has impressed at 9. Everyone else competent enough. Shows the difference in standards it must be said. What are the Seppos? Somewhere around 15th or 16th in the world?

TheCrowFliesBackwards
One of the Pack
TheCrowFliesBackwards
24 days ago

Still a lot of 1 out in attack

Reds Harry
Reds Harry
24 days ago

Such a shame the red card as the backs looked good early.

Reds Harry
Reds Harry
24 days ago

Very instructive performance and pretty good so far from A. Felia red carded for a high shot, guy ducked into it.
In common with most rugby games these days, winning contested kicks critical and Aus doing pretty well on that front, Pietsch outstanding in the air.
Amatosero makes a few errors, still a work in progress. Pack going well by and large. Hastie at halfback does not look out of place.
This is so much more useful than endless training camps.

Wooliej
Wooliej
24 days ago
Reply to  Reds Harry

High shot was too high, even if opponent ducked a bit. Silly behaviour by Aus player

Reds Harry
Reds Harry
24 days ago
Reply to  Wooliej

No argument from me for the yellow. But I thought red was harsh given the height drop.

Wooliej
Wooliej
24 days ago

I’m loving the US commentary-so informative, explaining the position of the player and what their role is.
Australia A showing a good display of running rugby, but discipline and defence not the best. Sound familiar?

luckyphil
One of the Pack
luckyphil
24 days ago
Reply to  Wooliej

I listened to a few of the games they commentated during the Winter games. I like them. A bit of hype, a bit informative and thanksfully none of Justin Harrison’s intellectual monologues that add no value at all. Oh and minimal criticism of the ref’s decisions.

TheCrowFliesBackwards
One of the Pack
TheCrowFliesBackwards
24 days ago

Forgot that it was on. Just tuned in at half time

21
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x