
Wallabies Player Ratings v Japan
What does one make of the new coach’s first game? Around ten o’clock on Saturday night, through goggle-eyes, I wasn’t too pleased with that win. But after reviewing the game, I’m not so down about it. The real winner in Osaka was the weather: high temperature and high humidity. Why do they do it?
Rating Scale
Anyway, this is my take on the Aussie players, on the good old Roar 1–10 rating system:
- Please don’t pick him again
- Had a stinker
- Got more wrong than he got right
- Not one of his best outings
- Par for the course
- Did most things well
- Had a good game
- Had a great game
- Blinder
- John Eales

Starting XV Ratings
- Aidan Ross – 6: Ross had a couple of carries and made 11 tackles in half a game. His core role is scrumming, and the only time his scrum was dominated was when a man was off the field. Though he was involved in one of those passes out the back that went to ground.
- Josh Nasser – 6: My notes were devoid of Nasser’s involvement; this means he must have got his core roles correct. A couple of runs and also 11 tackles, but he missed two as well. All his lineouts were good.
- Allan Alaalatoa – 5: 53 minutes in the heat, got turned over once, and went close to proving why props never kick right on half-time.
- Josh Canham – 8: I don’t recall if he got man of the match—Gibbo rang straight after fulltime and I missed the post-match on Stan—but he should have. A lineout steal straight from Dearns’ hands, and won a ruck pilfer penalty. Turned the ball over once and fell off a tackle; otherwise a 9.
- Miles Amatosero – 3: Red carded in his second Test. Before that he was strong in defence, 10 tackles in 30 minutes, and a couple of hit-ups. Will he get another chance, or is this what LSL needed to become a regular again?
- Rob Valetini – 6: Not really as much involvement as we are used to seeing from him. 12 tackles and only 3 carries into contact. Also joined the poor pass out the back club, with one that went on the bounce to Meredith.
- Fraser McReight – 7: A game-high 21 tackles with no misses and ran for 43 metres. Penalised once, but he’s a 7 and is living on that line.
- Harry Wilson – 5: 14 tackles and 11 carries is a good work rate, but was penalised twice and fell off two tackles. Was it the captain talking to the ref that got them marched 10m towards the end of the game? I wonder what was said.
- Ryan Lonergan – 7: Basically had a good game, but put one box kick out on the full and only averaged 23 metres from his 5 exit kicks to reach 37 metres out. 4 out of 4 conversions kept his rating at 7.
- Declan Meredith – 4: Was solid enough on both sides of the ball, until he wasn’t. Averaged 20m from his 4 exit kicks to not make it past 30. Nailed a couple of long-range penalties for 5m lineouts. Knocked the ball on from a scrum move, kick-off went out on the fly, and made a quick tap that was a poor decision and had poor execution (that was a coach killer). Won one turnover by ripping in a tackle.
- Harry Potter – 7.5: Match-high metres gained of 118m and a lovely try after picking up a loose ball 25m out. Had some quality involvements, like jumping from out of play to turn over a Japanese penalty for a 5m lineout (a move I personally don’t like). But misjudged the only high kick that came his way and was penalised for playing the ball on the ground after a successful kick chase.
- Hunter Paisami – 5: 15 tackles and 10 carries for 55m. But missed 3 tackles—one when he rushed up, his other hallmark move beside his dumb kicks. Threw a bad offload after making a half-break and made his usual dumb grubber when 10m out and under penalty advantage.
- Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii – 4: Won a turnover but lost two. Bad timing for a planned pass out the back from Ross early on. Was out-jumped by an opponent from a high kick. 8 tackles and 6 runs. Had 4 good minutes after Kiss’s half-time talk then rushed out and left a gate for Ueda in the 44th minute. The $6 Million Dollar Enigma.
- Max Jorgensen – 5: Didn’t get much of a chance, but didn’t stuff it up when called on.
- Tom Wright – 4.5: Got a lot of chances and only made half of them come off. Scored a nice try, but lost half a point for two low-percentage kicks in the second half that turned the ball over when on attack (I wonder if he’s sharing with Hunter). Was out-jumped in his 22 from a high kick. Took an out the back pass from Nasser and didn’t know what to do, so threw a long looping pass that should have been intercepted, but led to a Japanese knock-back and a regather and good field position. Dropped a pass when we again ran the ball from our own 22, which we somehow regathered and exited from. But won a probable try-saving ruck penalty 10m from his own line. Rocks and diamonds.
Bench, Coaching & Final Wrap-Up
The Forwards Bench – 6.5: The bench forwards all pulled their weight and did at least as good as those they replaced. The scrum after a good first half became more dominant after Tupou came on, something that hopefully can be utilised better next week.
The Backs Bench – 5: McDermott averaged more metres from his exits, but only by a metre or two. Donaldson and Henry were consolation caps.
The Coach – 5: A win in his first Test was a positive; winning by 3 over Japan only highlights how money in rugby can buy you happiness. His original selection of the 23 was a good blend of established players and rising prospects, giving experience. His replacements of Donaldson to fullback, Wright to wing, then Henry to wing, was disruptive and, when only 7–10 points ahead, could have been a real mistake.
The Referees – 6: Eoghan Cross was consistent throughout and got most calls right—that’s what we want from the ref. The TMO, well, what can I say that hasn’t already been said?
The Wallabies – 6: A win is a win. The conditions were harsh, and so it’s hard to judge how a winter sport can be played in the summer to the level we would like to see. Kept the penalty count down below ten, which is where it’s got to stay. This year we seem to have got on top of our kick-off receipts that were regularly resulting in turning over points in previous years; just need to get better distance exits. A McReight quick tap and a Potter kick chase both led to big metre gains, but then turnovers. It wasn’t, as I’ve heard, a poor decision from McReight—he made 35m, and that’s more than Meredith’s usual kick length. That one and Potter’s were a complete lack of knowing what to do when you’re in a good position without support. The Wallabies’ inability to make the most of penalty advantages in the opposition 22 is a work on for Kiss also. But the bottom line was we won a close game that was there for the losing. 5 conversions out of 5 was an essential part of that result.




Wallabies (15-1): Tom Wright, Max Jorgensen, Isaac Henry, Hunter Paisami, Harry Potter, Carter Gordon, Ryan Lonergan, Harry Wilson (c), Carlo Tizzano, Charlie Cale, Lukhan Salakaia-Loto, Lachlan Shaw, Taniela Tupou, Josh Nasser, Angus Bell
Reserves: Brandon Paenga-Amosa, Aidan Ross, Massimo De Lutiis, Jeremy Williams, Fraser McReight, Tate McDermott, Ben Donaldson, Filipo Daugunu
De Lutiis for 1000
Multiple changes for Japan to emulate Italy v Rennie 22 and Schmidt 25
I’m nervous
Wallabies by 24
I hear Suaalii is out with a hamstring injury.
Can only increase the scoreline surely we agree
It’s a chance for someone else to put their name on the 13 guernsey, no one has had a chance since he came over to learn rugby at test level. Either someone grabs that chance or Swarley will be confirmed as the best 13 in Australia, if no one can play better we really are up that creek
So Henry has that chance, but Japan are not an easy team to play due to their freneticism
Roger Rogerson
Thanks Mirt and pretty much agree with your ratings.
I think we need Carter Gordon and his passing gasme to help unlock the backs. Both Lenny and Hunter pass the ball as the last resort, and as a result put JAS and the outside backs under pressure.
It seems like the coaches don’t have a plan to use the skills of players like JAS and Max.
IMO Jorgenson a 6.5 or 7.
Jorgenson did a lot with the chances he had.
He setup Wright’s try with a draw and pass. He scored a try at a vital time.8 runs for 50 metres. He made a line break only potter made more. 2 defenders beaten. He made an offload. So did a lot on the carries he had. Made 10 tackles missed 2. Ddin’t give away any penalties. He won a turnover. He also gave away 1 turnover.
Other than Jorgo I am fairly happy with your ratings.
Good call. I certainly may have got the wingers ratings a bit wrong. Letting the flashy runs overshadow the solid work
I think Potter at 7.5 is generous, but he went looking for work, unlike Max, who it appears does not have the roving skillset nailed down.
I would like to see JAS do the SBW (Sonny Bill) thing at 12 just once and this next game would be ideal. Henry to 13.
Harry was penalised the extra 10, for throwing the ball way, you must have had your head in fridge
JAS needs a seismic shock to see if he was/is a good investment. IMO move him to Reds
Just a thought…… Nawaqanitawase has centre experience in younger days and in NRL.
I’d like to see Henry at 13 and Swarley on the bench in Townsville
Playing Marky Mark in the centres would be a disaser. There is a reason he was tried in the centres in the NRL and was moved back to the wing.
Sorry, I forgot to alliterate
That made me laugh mate
Nice round up, Mirtle. Good to see you kept notes but it must have looked like shorthand with the amount of trips you were making to the fridge,
It was raining this morning, so I got a second viewing under the influence of coffee, that’s where the notes came in