Mirt’s Wallaby Team to Take on Ireland

The team should be out on Thursday, I guess, so here’s your chance to get in first and advise Mr. Schmidt on the best course of action.

A while back, I picked my squad and got a few wrong. But now, with the help of Schmidt’s 36-man squad, I feel the need to put forth the obvious Aussie XV that will trot out on Saturday night.

The Initial Lineup Recap

From my 20 May article, I picked the following 15:

  1. Bell
  2. Pollard
  3. Tupou
  4. Frost
  5. Salakaia-Loto
  6. Hooper
  7. McReight
  8. Wilson
  9. Gordon
  10. Donaldson
  11. Jorgensen
  12. Ikitau
  13. Suaalii
  14. Daugunu
  15. Wright

Some very judicious choices there, Mirtle, well done. However, there’s a few names there that stand out as being, well, left out.

Forced Changes and Tactics

Frost and Salakaia-Loto, my chosen locks, didn’t make the grade, so maybe later in the year for them, or maybe they spit the dummy and take up northern paycheques. Now, who to replace them with? I think one of the main reasons Salakaia-Loto was left out was the failure of the Reds’ lineout, which came good again once Canham came back from injury, so I’m going with him and the overall work rate of Williams.

At halfback, I had the boring, box-kicking, level-headed Gordon, who went and broke himself. So, to replace him, I’m bringing in Lonergan, as I like his pass and feel that McDermott is better utilised off the bench, as previously. This may all depend on Joe Schmidt’s game plan, though.

After reconsideration, I believe there are some other changes to my original team that need to be implemented as well.

Tweaking the Forwards and Backs

Upfront, I’ll stick with Bell but bring in Alaalatoa to start and use Tupou for the last 30. And between them, I believe Paenga-Amosa has shown enough to be the starting rake.

The loose three has been defensively lacking for some time, and while I think Schmidt will probably stick with his Valetini-McReight-Wilson trio, I am dropping Valetini to the bench to replace Wilson at 55 min and bringing in Hooper to start.

I’ll stick with Donaldson at 10. Though Gordon has proved himself able with the tee in games of late, I think his out-of-hand kicking lets him down at times.

The centres are all we have. I don’t much like the overall Ikitau-Suaalii combination, but we have no other 12 to allow Ikitau to move to 13, and no other 13 to force Suaalii to play wider. This is a real weakness in the team. But Joe has run with it almost exclusively, and there might eventually be a payoff, especially if Suaalii can bring some mongrel like in his last ‘Tahs game.

On the wing, I’ll stick with Jorgensen but use Daugunu off the bench and bring Pietsch into the XV. I’d like to see Campbell play at the back but think Schmidt will go with Wright.

My Predicted XV for the Weekend

So my XV for the weekend is (with the bench in brackets):

  • 1 Bell (Slipper)
  • 2 Paenga-Amosa (Pollard)
  • 3 Alaalatoa (Tupou)
  • 4 Canham (Amatosero)
  • 5 Williams
  • 6 Hooper
  • 7 McReight
  • 8 Wilson (Valetini)
  • 9 Lonergan (McDermott)
  • 10 Donaldson (Gordon)
  • 11 Jorgensen
  • 12 Ikitau
  • 13 Suaalii
  • 14 Pietsch (Daugunu)
  • 15 Wright

Anyway, I hope we rip the Irish a new one, whoever’s in the team. The pussy powers have given them the soft ride, with a trip up the highway for their next away game, whilst their opponent has to fly from Japan and back again for the second of three home games. That’s as raw as steak tartare.

Avatar photo

Mirt

mirt is The Underdog's Wallabies ratings man, running the rule over every player after each Test using the Underdog 1–10 scale. Also behind team picks, Top 6 predictions and tipping comps, mirt writes as a fan who watches every minute and isn't shy about calling it as he sees it, even when seeing double thru his red tinted eyes

Articles: 20
Subscribe
Notify of
8 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Barney
Barney
4 months ago

I think most controversial thing you said or intimated was that Joe has a game plan

farcanal
farcanal
4 months ago

A very tough assignment straight up but will get them battle Hardend.
Ireland by 15 at least if wallaby’s stay close or cause an upset well done

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
4 months ago

I think you need 5 legit ball carriers in a pack two legit poachers..Bell TT Bobby Hooper and I would have had LSL with a Canham or a Frost prior too squad announcement,now I don’t know what’s Joe’s plan…Could have played LSL and Holly as locks and bought in a leaping 6 like Cale and Bobby at 8 which on time with Kiss will be the back 6 in my opinion for the simple reason is Hooper is undroppable and Cale showed in bear future a different string too out now.Joe is hooked on the notion of Harry captain and 8 and it’s worked but more often than not it doesn’t .Shaw Williams lock combo looks light on for ball carrying and at least one lock has to get over gainline that’s why Miles Canham combo looks interesting for the future with a Hooper 6 at least than you get past gainline and secure lineout which we will struggle to do this Saturday as always..

luckyphil
One of the Pack
luckyphil
4 months ago

I think you are pretty close. Can’t help feel we are light on with the 4/5, but I suppose having Hooper at 6 carries it a bit.

Based on previous games I wouldn’t be surprised if Joe went with the following, but this would leave us exposed if a lock was injured early:
4 – Hooper (Canham or Amatosero)
5 – Williams
6 – Valetini
7 – McReight (Tizzano)
8 – Harry Wilson

Aaron Ruka
One of the Pack
Aaron Ruka
4 months ago

I really like the Aussie loosies, id take them over the All Blacks every day of the week. If The Wallabies could get a good tight 5 together they could be a threat to everyone, just look at Ellis Park last year

Last edited 4 months ago by Aaron Ruka
8
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x