RUPA vs Rugby Australia Pay Dispute: Who’s Winning?

Fair Case, Fine Print, Fumbled Pitch

The Wallabies are holed up in a London hotel getting ready for England, and back home their bosses and their union are going at each other like a scrum on the 5-metre line. The collective bargaining agreement ran out on Saturday 31 October, nobody blinked, and the pay war has gone from boardroom grumbling to letters, lawyers and a looming court date.

Here’s the bit that stings. On the stuff that actually matters to a young bloke on minimum wage, the players have the better argument. And right now, they’re losing it anyway.

The Letter That Lit the Fuse

On Tuesday 3 November, Rugby Australia chief executive Phil Waugh wrote to every professional player in the country, laying out the offer from the Rugby Bodies, which is RA and the Super Rugby clubs. Waugh called it the first chance RA had to put its position to the players directly, and he wasn’t shy with the numbers.

  • A minimum of $158.5 million in player payments
  • The players’ share of gross player revenue up from 29% to 32%
  • Men’s national contract funding up a third to $8 million a year
  • The Women’s Integrated Rugby Program up 90% to $3.5 million, with the number of full-time Wallaroos doubled
  • The Super Rugby salary cap floor up from $4.5 million to $5 million, reaching $5.8 million by 2030
  • Minimum salaries of $65,000 for full-time players and $85,000 for core players, rising $2,500 a year
  • Wallabies win bonuses up from $12,000 to $20,000, for Rugby Championship and Bledisloe Tests only
  • $175,000 per squad member to win a home World Cup, including $50,000 for a semi-final win, paid equally to the Wallabies in 2027 and the Wallaroos in 2029

The letter also reminded players that their individual contracts still bind them to commercial appearances, media and broadcast duties, social posts on 24 hours’ notice and team kit rules, with Wallabies Team Protocols still in force on tour. Read between the lines and that’s RA heading off any sponsor boycotts or protest gear before anyone gets ideas.

Write for The Underdog - submit your rugby article

What the Headline Numbers Leave Out

On paper, that’s a tidy package. Plenty of fans have looked at it, looked at the Bledisloe scorelines, and decided the players should take the money and run. It’s an easy reaction, but it misses who this deal is actually for.

The Rugby Union Players’ Association represents roughly 400 professionals: Super Rugby squads, women’s players, sevens and the pathway kids. The Wallabies are the face of it, but the CBA is the pool everyone else drinks from. Sources close to the talks say the two sides started tens of millions of dollars apart on minimum wage spending over a five-year deal. That gap narrowed, but it was still significant when the clock ran out. Two of the biggest sticking points were who pays private health insurance premiums and how career-ending injury cover gets funded.

The Robertson Case

Western Force prop Tom Robertson, 38 Tests and in his third year as RUPA president, put the human face on it. He says young players on minimum wage and below are moving interstate, often leaving home for the first time, paying for their own private health cover, then copping thousands of dollars upfront for surgery and waiting to be reimbursed. Some are working second jobs, borrowing off family and mates, or leaning on credit cards just to reach a liveable wage.

That’s not a greedy union talking. That’s a young player wondering whether his next operation comes out of his own pocket. Robertson says RUPA’s Player Advisory Group has looked at RA’s offer and knocked it back, and that under the current terms, players would actually go backwards.

All.Rugby - rugby stats and results, proud stats partner of The Underdog

RA’s Side of the Ledger

RA chairman Dan Herbert, himself a RUPA president back in 2002 and 2003, isn’t buying it. He says RA only climbed out of debt within the last year, and that the hosting fees from the 2027 and 2029 home World Cups are one-off money that has to set the whole game up for the long haul, not get burned on permanent wage rises. That’s the same reported $100 million hosting fee RUPA had already called it unacceptable for players to miss out on.

Herbert pointed to the aftermath of the 2003 World Cup as the cautionary tale. He says RUPA’s demands go beyond what Australian rugby revenue can support, accused the current leadership of losing sight of its own charter, for the players and the game, and made a point of saying his fight is with RUPA’s leadership, not the players.

Fair cop on the sums. Nobody who has lived through the last couple of decades of Australian rugby’s finances wants the World Cup cheque spent by 2029. The real question is whether insurance for a 20-year-old on minimum wage is where the game goes broke.

Losing the War of Words

This is where RUPA is shooting itself in the foot. RA has put its entire offer in writing, in the players’ inboxes and in the papers. RUPA has given us strong stories and no figures. Robertson says players go backwards, but we haven’t seen the sums. RUPA says its revised proposals have substantially narrowed the gap, but not what those proposals are.

So every day, the only numbers anyone can quote are RA’s, and RA gets to look like the reasonable adult in the room. The general mood among fans is pretty clear: show us your numbers and we might come round. Instead, they’ve had a players’ trust, a legal threat and shots fired in a Test week, with the team overseas and the public still sore from the Bledisloe.

The Letter, the Trust and the Court Date

RUPA does have a genuine grievance about the letter. Robertson says RA asked twice to present directly to the players, player leaders weren’t comfortable with it, and RA went ahead anyway once the CBA lapsed, while the Wallabies were on tour. Herbert counters that RA asked several times, respected the bargaining protocols while the deal was live, and only wrote once it had expired, to assure players their pay and entitlements would be honoured.

Then there’s the Rugby Union Players’ Property Trust, which RUPA says has held the name, image and likeness rights of every player who signed a deed with it since 1 November. RA says it can’t override what’s already in individual contracts. Robertson says similar structures exist in other sports and other rugby nations, and the aim is to grow the pie commercially. That one looks headed for the NSW Supreme Court, with a hearing expected as early as Friday 6 November.

Support The Underdog – black Underdog rugby t-shirt

Where It Lands

Both sides say a deal is still within reach, and both say the other one has to move. RUPA chief executive Adrian Turner says the ball is in RA’s court. Robertson says the gap has narrowed. Herbert says the gap is real.

Meanwhile, the Wallabies face England with assistant coach Jonny Fisher insisting the jersey is everything to this group and the rest is in the hands of the people they’ve trusted to sort it. Kurtley Beale reckons he isn’t across the detail. The sevens start their World Series campaigns later this month and Super Rugby squads are back for preseason, all without a deal.

The players have the better case on welfare. If RUPA wants the public in their corner, the fix is simple: put the numbers on the table, show us exactly where players go backwards, and make RA defend its insurance terms out loud. Until then, RA keeps winning the press conference. A couple of wins up north wouldn’t hurt either.

🐾 Want to help The Underdog grow?

We’re independent and reader-built. One click tells Google you want to see more of us, so our stories reach more rugby fans in Top Stories.

⭐ Add The Underdog on Google
Avatar photo

Ben Casey

Ben Casey is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of The Underdog. An outback country publican and independent sports analyst, Ben brings decades of grassroots rugby experience and tactical knowledge to his reporting. Frustrated by mainstream clickbait, he specializes in deep-dive Super Rugby analysis, honest match reporting, and holding Australian sports governance to a higher standard.

Articles: 471
Subscribe
Notify of
22 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Mirt
One of the Pack
Mirt
12 days ago

Whatever happened to workers compensation.

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
12 days ago

After the Bled cup my heart is what about trying harder to earn more…

farcanal
farcanal
12 days ago
Reply to  Antonio lover

Speak English my friend they hard around here bring back the roar

farcanal
farcanal
12 days ago
Reply to  Antonio lover

Thing is everyone seen how easily we rolled to the blacks so teams allready have a game plan for our wallaby’s and if kissy keeps calling our great game FOOTY we ain’t a chance against the poms

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
12 days ago
Reply to  farcanal

That fast ruck ball quick phase stuff we both play is still the best way ABS just lay it better…when the Blacks get beaten it’s from amazing defensive displays.. Wallabies aren’t known for that.

luckyphil
One of the Pack
luckyphil
12 days ago

As you say Ben, the RUPA is not winning the case in the court of public opinion.

IMO, the players have no claim against the $100 million from hosting the RWC. Maybe a portion of it (due to the games they play in) but this is probably pnly about 10% of the full amount at best. This money needs to be invested in growing the sport, not helping pay for Harry Wilson’s $900,000 income (and yes I just made this up).

Secondly, contracted players should not be copping thousands of dollars upfront for surgery and waiting to be reimbursed. In no world is that acceptable and RA/States should be ashamed of themselves letting this happen – if indeed it is a widespread problem.

Finally, players at the bottom of the pile are there for a reason. They are either early on in their professional career or are fringe players. A healthy professional environment need both of them. That said, I have no issues with the RUPA pushing for this to be increased, but the players also need to realise that people pay to go to University (not being paid $65,000 to learn it) and there are plenty of people earning $85,000 a year.

Muglair
Muglair
6 days ago
Reply to  Ben Casey

The irony is this caused by RA continually making claims that the RWC has somehow made rugby wealthy. By the time the $100m comes in half will probably just recoup accrued losses, then what is the story for funding the WRWC?

We should be getting this information as rugby stakeholders, being a paying customer flows from being a stakeholder, something RA does not understand. Keep crapping on stakeholders and you will have no customers.

Muglair
Muglair
13 days ago

What a load of self entitled rubbish. There are a lot more than 400 elite world class athletes training this morning for the love of their sport and their desire to be the best in the world. If Australian professional teams were at that level then perhaps they would win some games, attract more of a crowd and there would be more money to pay them.

Professional football players have won the lottery, doing something most people would do for free, get paid for it, and have an opportunity to head to the biggest global stages and earn a great deal of money. Instead they get to a level in the Australian game, a long way down the global pecking order, and have an expectation an organisation losing money because you are not very good pays you a larger income.

The argument would be far different if Australian teams were winning and the elite game was generating enough surplus to fund community rugby and its growth. It’s legal function. Worse it is circular, if the game supported community rugby there would be a lot more community commercial support for professional rugby. Phil Kearns words after winning the RWC2027 bid. Remember back when the $100m was earmarked to reward long suffering community rugby.

Junior players learning their trade do not earn enough money? How well off is any young person starting out on a career? They have to pay their education costs, find a job and work hard. 40+ hours a week. Players are mostly naturally talented but apart from their own efforts there is massive input from volunteers and the Australian rugby ecosystem.

The real problem is we have too many SRP teams with too many players not ready for that level of competition. We need fewer SRP teams where players can perhaps be paid more, together with more NRC teams playing more games on a semi professional basis. RA has lost massive amounts of money operating the professional game since 1995, almost covered by three Lions Tours and the 2003 RWC windfall.

Medical costs should obviously be covered but I am not sure what insurance for career ending injuries is. Getting out of bed every day opens us all to many life threatening, career threatening, potentially financially catastrophic risks. There needs to be short term income protection for some period. I assume existing contracts are honoured but it would be scary for a player coming off contract. Perhaps there should be a minimum period of cover covered either by the contract or insurance.

Phil Board
One of the Pack
Phil Board
12 days ago
Reply to  Muglair

Your comments are valid but I’d like to expand on the junior players learning their trade.

Yes, I agree 100% that 18 -20 year olds need to do the hard yards BUT those in the development squads are expected to do it twice! They all have to work 40+ hours per week in a “real job” outside of rugby and then they are expected to dedicate early mornings in the gym, every evening on the training field (for academy and club – often on the same night). By the time many get home after gym + work + training they grab whatever meal is convenient and then fall into bed before doing it all over again.

Doing the hard yards builds character and resilience, and those who make it to the top squads look back fondly on the struggle.

BUT, surely the system (RA, RUPA, franchise) can pay them more than petrol money to keep them motivated. Even a 1st year apprentice gets $600/week.

Muglair
Muglair
6 days ago
Reply to  Phil Board

That is my point, what do you think aspiring amateur athletes do? At one point in my life I trained 12-14 times a week over extended periods for around five years. I doubt if development rugby players do that much.

Bummer I gave it away the year before petrol money came in, and probably two or three years before I believe I could be the best I could be, but as I am sure they still say, you can’t eat gold medals. You have to make life choices and if you want to be THE BEST then everything else is secondary. The problem for rugby and soccer is there is too much money in the local game allowing players to have their cake and eat it too without having to reach their potential best.

Even so there are a large number of them absorbing significant investment when only a few progress to the next level, and even the best are not producing a financial surplus at their peak. They should not be complaining at the moment as the loss making business model advances too many of them to the next level where they still get paid more than they are worth.

Maybe the motivation is money, I probably tend to think it is the ambition of many younger players to get a contract and they put in a few years of intense effort. When they realise they can’t they often leave 1st grade rugby as well. Champions are not driven by money, they survive until they can be their best. Some of those younger players may just have needed another three years sacrifice.

Mirt
One of the Pack
Mirt
13 days ago

Insurance, the big winner again. Hey, lets get some lawyers involved, thatll fix it

Phil Board
One of the Pack
Phil Board
12 days ago
Reply to  Mirt

RA’s player insurance from U8s right up to the elite level is an absolute disgrace. It’s the insurance you have when you don’t have insurance. EVERY medical expense that has any Medicare rebate component is excluded from the claim. Parents need to have private health insurance just to cover a percentage of expenses, even then there are still significant out-of-pocket expenses if there’s a need for surgery or extended rehab.

Mirt
One of the Pack
Mirt
12 days ago
Reply to  Phil Board

I paid for my own insurance all the way thru my working life, never once thought of asking my employers or my business partners to cover it for me. How dumb was I

Phil Board
One of the Pack
Phil Board
12 days ago
Reply to  Mirt

It’s easy to be flippant when you don’t have the facts. Every player’s registration fees include a % that covers the RA insurance premium, so they are all paying for their own insurance – a cover that is woefully inadequate.

Mirt
One of the Pack
Mirt
12 days ago
Reply to  Phil Board

Flippant or not , I still paid my own insurance

farcanal
farcanal
12 days ago
Reply to  Phil Board

Facts facts mirt don’t understand facts but hes a great contributor on a great site. The new roar where we are all a bit out there…well I are

Last edited 12 days ago by farcanal
TheCrowFliesBackwards
One of the Pack
TheCrowFliesBackwards
12 days ago
Reply to  farcanal

You on the Jacks again, Farkers?

farcanal
farcanal
12 days ago

Just run out mate, plenty beers left so should behave, back to 3n1 Monday 84 plus a week, apologies to all did 2 litres alone 4 days plus beers, tapering off now crow I should slowly start to make sense

Last edited 12 days ago by farcanal
luckyphil
One of the Pack
luckyphil
11 days ago
Reply to  Mirt

Strongly disagree with this Mirt. If you are employed in a role that puts you at high risk of injury like sport does, the employer should insure them.

After all, none of them could get income protection insurance except through their employer.

I have to pay into workers compensation to cover our employees and there is very little chance they will get injured, so why shouldn’t rugby clubs do the same.

22
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x