Wallabies Player Ratings v Argentina

Three months after winning the Bledisloe Cup in a one-off game, the Wallabies, with Bob Templeton in charge for the first game of his third reign, went to Argentina for the first time. They were beaten in the first-ever test between the two nations; a week later, they evened the score. From then until 2003, there were 17 games played in those 24 years, with the Wallabies winning at a rate of 3 to 1.

There was a hiatus for almost a decade before, in 2012, Argentina entered the Rugby Championship. Since then, there have been another 26 games with Australia maintaining its 3 to 1 win rate. However, the tale of the Rugby Championship years is a tale of two different trends. From 2012, through Deans, McKenzie, and Cheika, Australia won 13 of the next 15 games played. The years after the 2019 World Cup have seen Argentina close the gap, with the Wallabies winning only 5 of the 11 games since.

There’s probably a book to be written on why this has happened, with some blaming RA, some blaming Giteau, and some probably even blaming me, but it basically comes down to player involvement in the UK and Europe, which has worked in Argentina’s favour and against Australia’s.

So follows my take on the Aussie players, on the new The Underdog 1–10 rating system.

The Underdog 1–10 Rating Scale

  • 1: Deadset liability
  • 2: Absolute Barry Crocker
  • 3: A bit of a dog’s breakfast
  • 4: Yeah, nah, not his best
  • 5: Punched the clock
  • 6: Earned his post-match tinnie
  • 7: Gave it a red-hot go
  • 8: Absolute ripper
  • 9: Played a deadset blinder
  • 10: John Eales

Team Overview

The Wallabies – 7

A big win is a big win. Last game I said, “A game like that against a higher ranked opponent would probably make me give an 8 or 9”, but even though Argentina were ranked higher than us and we were playing over there, I still find myself not being able to go higher than a 7 for this game. Maybe when they double it up next week. Again, it was a game of rocks and diamonds, with the Wallabies doing just as many poor things as great things.

The lineout and scrums were solid, the passing and handling is still improving but not where it needs to be, and the kicking from hand leaves a bit to be desired. The win came off the back of an excellent effort from the forward pack, both starters and bench, again outscoring the backs, this time 3 tries to 1. The backs looked good at times but were unable to finish off the few breaks they made. Kick receiving and chasing was not really good enough, but this seemed to be the only time the wingers could get involved. Henry, through no fault of his own, was almost invisible. All in all, this was the type of solid team effort that can lead us somewhere.

Player Ratings

The Front Row

  • 1. Isaac Kailea – 6
  • 2. B. Paenga-Amosa – 6
  • 3. Allan Alaalatoa – 6
  • 16. Billy Pollard – 6
  • 17. Angus Bell – 6
  • 18. Massimo de Lutiis – 6

All these front rowers did their job. Won all their scrums. Missed only 1 of 30 tackles between them. Turned the ball over only once between them, but gave away 4 penalties. That’s the solid, hard-working effort that we need to keep up.

Second Row & Loose Forwards

  • 4. Josh Canham – 8 Won a lineout steal. Was involved in pretty much everything. Striding out for Amosa’s try was a thing of beauty, then changing his line and slipping a pass to Williams going the other way—gimme more.
  • 5. Jeremy Williams – 7 Won a lineout steal. Was right there with Canham, though he gave away a penalty and knocked on once.
  • 6. Tom Hooper – 7 Won a couple of penalties at the ruck (was fortunately called back by BOK when he tried a quick tap from one), scored a try, more carries and metres and tackles than Canham, but missed a couple of tackles, was turned over once, and threw a poor pass.
  • 7. Fraser McReight – 7 Busy all the time without being a standout. Scored a try and won a ruck penalty in his own 22 (really becoming a trademark play of his). Handling was a bit dodgy—ball went straight through his hands before Williams knocked on, and dropped the pass from Donaldson after a break with 10 sec on the clock.
  • 8. Bobby Valetini – 9 Carries, metres carried, and tackles were the highest of all the forwards—that’s work rate and effort. His ability to get over the advantage line with most carries was a major factor in our ability to mount pressure. Held up an Argie forward in the 23rd minute, turned the ball over 3 minutes later 5m from the line, and made one of the ugliest clearance kicks I’ve seen—at least it went 40m.

Halves & Backline

  • 9. Ryan Lonergan – 7 Basically had a good game due to his main core skill, passing. Averaged 30m with his exit kicks from the 22 and only made 1 box kick which was won by Jorgensen. Won the chase to an Argentine chip when we were down a man, saving a try. Was lucky not to be penalised a couple of times when pretending to catch a high kick and running a blocking line—once the ball almost landed on his head, he should be trying to actually catch these.
  • 10. Carter Gordon – 6 Scored a try with quick thinking. Made a try-saving cover tackle just before their first try. Passed a lot more than he carried and made a couple of dodgy kicks in general play: a Paisami-style grubber that didn’t come off and one that went dead from 45m out.
  • 11. Harry Potter – 3 He appeared the most of all players in my notes, with 12 entries. He chased deep kick-offs well, winning the ball once and stopping them in their 22 on another occasion. His only other positive involvements were immediately followed by errors: finally caught one of their high kicks but threw a dodgy pass after it, then regathered a box kick but was immediately turned over. Caught 1 of 4 high kicks that came his way, regathered 1 of 3 box kicks he chased. Was yellow-carded and then penalised for offside in the 77th minute.
  • 12. Hunter Paisami – 5 Not bad stats: 9 carries for 54m, actually passed 9 times (I’ll need to watch again to see how many didn’t go to Henry). Was instrumental in the Argentine first try—the original break went between him and Kailea but was more of a classic move than a defensive error, then he was stood up 40 metres downfield and 2 phases later by the try scorer chopping back inside him and Wright (these didn’t even count as any of his three missed tackles as he didn’t lay a hand on them). Made one very poor pass right before halftime. Made some really good runs just before the hour mark, then helped Suaalii on his way a couple of times with good hands.
  • 13. Isaac Henry – 5 Very little involvement. But made no mistakes, turned the ball over once.
  • 14. Max Jorgensen – 6 Was only beaten to the ball on one occasion for the 4 box kicks he chased, but one of them was badly directed and he was immediately put into touch, and one he slapped back but it was gathered by an Argie, so really only 1 of 4 ended in a win. Missed a rush-up tackle that resulted in a disallowed Argentine try. A couple of dominant tackles: one early where he chased a kick and tackled then won a ruck turnover, another where he forced a player into touch. One of the core roles of a winger is to chase kicks for touch—27th minute, Gordon’s penalty touch finder didn’t go out, Jorgensen compounded this error by not chasing.
  • 15. Tom Wright – 4 Third minute he threw a shocker of a pass inside his own 22. Was stood up for ARG first try. Squashed Jorgensen for room then threw a difficult pass out of the back of his hand to put him under pressure. The game’s not even 20 min old yet. Didn’t do much else apart from two weak exit kicks from his 22 in the second half.

Substitutes

  • 19. Lachy Shaw – 6 20 min, no mistakes.
  • 20. Charlie Cale – 5 10 min, one lineout steal, two missed tackles.
  • 21. Tate McDermott – 4 32m from his one exit kick. Made 8 box kicks: 5 of them were well-weighted, one went 10m and came down on the sideline, one was charged down in his own 22, and another went straight up and landed in Argentine hands inside the 22 with 5 minutes on the clock. Made a beautiful long pass across the front of his forwards to no one in the 67th minute. Was unlucky to be held up from a quick tap in what was his only dart of the game. I thought his passing was better, but still at runners’ heads and not as long as Lonergan’s.
  • 22. Ben Donaldson – 4 20 min, missed a gettable conversion. Threw a poor pass to McReight after that break with 10 sec on the clock. But to really sum up where Donaldson is in test terms, have a look at the front-on replay of the offload he received from Canham in the 59th minute: rabbit in the headlights. He’s a handy Super-level player.
  • 23. Joseph Suaalii – 7 15 min, he played the exact game a team needs from a replacement back—maybe Kiss has found his position.

Coaching & Officiating

The Coach – 8

Again, I was dubious with all the changes, but Kiss is still trying to work out what his men can and can’t do. He used his bench players astutely and got good test minutes into some youngsters. I expect more of these changes to come next week, but possibly getting closer to the team he needs that will win back the Bledisloe in a month or two.

The Referees – 8

Ben O’Keeffe was excellent. The TMO made the right calls every time he was needed. This is what we want from them, thank you very much.

Predicted Wallabies Team for Next Week

I imagine Kiss will come up with a fair few changes for next week, but he has to settle into something more constant eventually.

  1. Angus Bell
  2. B. Paenga-Amosa
  3. Allan Alaalatoa
  4. Josh Canham
  5. Lukhan Salakaia-Loto
  6. Tom Hooper
  7. Carlo Tizzano
  8. Harry Wilson
  9. Tate McDermott (was Lonergan a head injury?)
  10. Tom Meredith
  11. Filipo Daugunu
  12. Len Ikitau
  13. Isaac Henry (Joseph Suaalii)
  14. Max Jorgensen
  15. Jock Campbell
  16. Josh Nasser
  17. Isaac Kailea
  18. Taniela Tupou
  19. Jeremy Williams
  20. Charlie Cale
  21. Kalani Thomas
  22. Carter Gordon
  23. Joseph Suaalii (Isaac Henry)
Avatar photo

Mirt

mirt is The Underdog's Wallabies ratings man, running the rule over every player after each Test using the Underdog 1–10 scale. Also behind team picks, Top 6 predictions and tipping comps, mirt writes as a fan who watches every minute and isn't shy about calling it as he sees it, even when seeing double thru his red tinted eyes

Articles: 20
Subscribe
Notify of
48 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Basos
Basos
2 months ago

I’m on a roll. This is what I asked CahtGPT: How many box kicks did Tait McDermott kick in the rugby game Argentina versus Australia last weekend?

The answer was:
In the Argentina v Australia Test on Saturday 29 August 2026, Tate McDermott made 8 box kicks after coming on as the replacement scrum-half.
Of those 8:

  • 5 were judged well weighted
  • 1 travelled only about 10 m
  • 1 was charged down inside Australia’s 22
  • 1 went almost straight up and was collected by Argentina inside the Australian 22 late in the match.

That is quite a high number considering McDermott was a replacement rather than the starting scrum-half. The match analysis specifically identified his kicking as one of Australia’s tactical problems.

Basos
Basos
2 months ago

If you want to have a laugh go to ChatGPT and enter – “How useful is a box kick in rugby union?” The usefulness of the kick depends on the distance of the kick, the hang time of the ball and how fast the chaser runs. I hope Tait McDermott has a look at the numbers because they are interesting. Don’t do this after 5 schooners.

Basos
Basos
2 months ago

I rewatched the game and focused on Tait. He made 4 useless box kicks and an Argie try resulted after a few plays from one of them. He made 3 useful box kicks. However, the box kicking was stupid play, only gave the ball back to the Argies and the Wallabies were lucky they were not punished more.

Basos
Basos
2 months ago
Reply to  Mirt

Agree mirt. Box kicks are low percentage play if they aren’t spot on.

Barney
Barney
2 months ago

Tis a shame, but your ratings for 11-15 were spot on. Think we have a backline problem…you bet we do

luckyphil
One of the Pack
luckyphil
2 months ago

@Mirt, I assume you are taking the p1$$ with your predicted team for next week. They need to focus on winning and getting ready for the Boks and ABs in a few weeks.

My team would be:

  1. Isaac Kailea
  2. B. Paenga-Amosa
  3. Allan Alaalatoa
  4. Josh Canham
  5. Lukhan Salakaia-Loto
  6. Tom Hooper
  7. Fraser McReight
  8. Harry Wilson (I’d prefer Bobby V, but expect him to bring back Harry)
  9. Ryan Lonergan
  10. Carter Gordon
  11. JAS
  12. Len Ikitau
  13. Isaac Henry
  14. Max Jorgensen
  15. Tom Wright
  16. Billy Pollard
  17. Angus Bell
  18. Taniela Tupou
  19. Jeremy Williams
  20. Charlie Cale / Bobby V
  21. Kalani Thomas
  22. Ben Donaldson
  23. Isaac Henry
farcanal
farcanal
2 months ago
Reply to  luckyphil

I think what he’s trying to say is Les probly has to do what Dave and Joe did but if it fails Les should not get harshly admonished because he knows Australia style or something

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
2 months ago
Reply to  Mirt

And again and again

luckyphil
One of the Pack
luckyphil
2 months ago
Reply to  farcanal

dribble dribble

Mungbean
Mungbean
2 months ago
Reply to  luckyphil

I like that team, but I’d give Tate another shot on the bench and you have Henry twice, so I’d replace the bench Henry with Daungunu

luckyphil
One of the Pack
luckyphil
2 months ago
Reply to  Mirt

as long as it is with another Qlder…

Piru
Piru
2 months ago

We better hope Lonergan is ok for next week, neither Gordon or Tate are game managers and apparently Donno will just fall apart if given the 10 jersey.

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
2 months ago
Reply to  Piru

Donno was poor last week it’s not easy coming on so late and fitting in but that was poor.

Ben Casey
Pack Leader
Ben Casey
2 months ago
Reply to  Antonio lover

I do want to see him have a crack from the start, but it’d worry me.

Piru
Piru
2 months ago
Reply to  Antonio lover

I’m actually not clear on what happened. I assume he came in because Lonergan had gone off and they needed his kicking (fat lot of good that was). But where was he playing? Fullback? He went in at first receiver for a bit but Gordon appeared again with the bandage round his head soon after.

Piru
Piru
2 months ago
Reply to  Mirt

Cheers. I was hungover so wasn’t my usual razor sharp self

luckyphil
One of the Pack
luckyphil
2 months ago
Reply to  Piru

I was confused too. I figured he must have just been bought on to take the kick and then went back off. Thought it was very Rassie style.

PeterK
One of the Pack
PeterK
2 months ago

BPA a 7 or 8.
He hit every target in the lineout. Strong scrum when he was there. He got the 1st try. One of the top tacklers and carries as well (per minute).

Jorgenson a 7. Made the only dominant tackles. Equal 1st for turnovers. Worked very hard off the ball. He was involved a lot at the breakdown unlike a lot of wingers.

Piru
Piru
2 months ago
Reply to  PeterK

Jorgo was channeling Pietsch in defence, I’ve never seen him lay big hits like that.

Also Williams I think was an 8, don’t forget his work that gave BPA the first try

Last edited 2 months ago by Piru
Sgt Pepperoni
Sgt Pepperoni
2 months ago

Good write up Mirt thanks

Tate and Donno didn’t get to 4. Dog’s breakfast or a Barry for sure

Is our pack carrying the backs? Seems like it

Maybe we need to get more forwards into the back line

Get the Tizz into 12, TT to fly half, Wilson to wing…

Tahs2win
Tahs2win
2 months ago
Reply to  Sgt Pepperoni

Angus Bell at 10, TT at 12 would be my preference.

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
2 months ago

Fair call…I think Lonergan passed fit already.TT will start Meredith? Is he in the squad after last game he played..JAS at 13 start Daugunu in place of Potter if Pietsch isn’t on tour.

PeterK
One of the Pack
PeterK
2 months ago
Reply to  Mirt

IMO much better would be Wilson out. But he will be there. If that is the case Valetini at 6 and T Hooper lock instead of LSL.
Much better would be JAS on wing instead of Potter or Duagunu. Ikitau at 13 and Henry at 12. But Kiss has ruled out JAS in the back 3, so that means Ikiatu 12 JAS 13. Wings should stay as they are Daugunu is more of a 13 or bench than winger now. If Pietsch is there yes he should take Potters spot.
Lonergan is fit so he and Gordon should start. Don’t think Meredith is on tour.
McDermott should be dropped but won’t be.
L

Ben Casey
Pack Leader
Ben Casey
2 months ago
Reply to  PeterK

Bobby V off the bench for me, more of a bomb squad type addition. I think coming in against a tiring pack and backs, he would demolish people.

I think Wilson’s leadership and ability to play 80 trumps, but I am unapologetic about being a Wilson fan.

This is not a slight against Bobby, plenty of top line players come off bench for SA and AB’s

PeterK
One of the Pack
PeterK
2 months ago
Reply to  Ben Casey

I would have Valetini start and Cale off the bench for more impact.
Valetini provides more most games than Wilson. Cale provides more impact. McReight as captain.

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
2 months ago
Reply to  Ben Casey

This will be Harry third bled cup series as captain if not injured and another series loss should end the captaincy in the real world …Can we all agree on that?

Ben Casey
Pack Leader
Ben Casey
2 months ago
Reply to  Antonio lover

I am all for Wilson, so we may have to agree to disagree haha

farcanal
farcanal
2 months ago
Reply to  Antonio lover

No

Mungbean
Mungbean
2 months ago
Reply to  Antonio lover

Wilson to stay as Captain for me!

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
2 months ago
Reply to  PeterK

Yeah Hooper must start Canham Hooper good lock pairing both won’t take a back step and offer different skill set that will compliment,I’ve got no Wilson and Cale 6.. lineout becomes a nightmare for opposition.

Last edited 2 months ago by Antonio lover
Ben Casey
Pack Leader
Ben Casey
2 months ago
Reply to  Mirt

Tupou and Hooper must be going back soon sadly. Military back in Oz so all ours

luckyphil
One of the Pack
luckyphil
2 months ago
Reply to  Ben Casey

I thought I heard TT was staying until the Boks game, but could be wrong. Again.

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
2 months ago
Reply to  luckyphil

Isn’t it the Bledisloe the prize until World cup years?Why aren’t we fielding our best teams for this series..

Ben Casey
Pack Leader
Ben Casey
2 months ago
Reply to  luckyphil

I haven’t heard anything specifically except for those with fingers on the pulse more then me saying they are surprised he’s still With us.

Top 14 starts next week.

Barney
Barney
2 months ago
Reply to  PeterK

I’ve said it before, I would try JAS at 12, playing à la SBW…Lenny would have a field day at 13…imo

Antonio lover
Antonio lover
2 months ago
Reply to  Barney

I don’t think he will pass at 12..I don’t think he has that deft touch to pass in contact like Ikitau it’s a very tricky skill to learn and most do one or the other .Kerevi developed it late in career and was brilliant.
..

Ben Casey
Pack Leader
Ben Casey
2 months ago
Reply to  Mirt

Love it mate and appreciate it

48
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x